![]() |
Santa is an alien |
So the Megan Kellys and Bill O'Reillys of the world should put a sock in it. Making political hay out of this non-issue is the height of stupidity.
And by the way, Happy Holidays!
A forum for posts that are of a musical, artistic, political, or personal nature. Some may be rants, some may be reviews, some may be ramblings of my disjointed mind. And I have two (formerly five) cockatiels, and a conure, hence the name "birdhaus". R.I.P. Boomer, Sunny Lou and Woody Jean.
![]() |
Santa is an alien |
Holiday Harangue: Utah Lawmaker Wants To Mandate `Merry Christmas'
By Rob Boston
The Religious Right's annual whine-fest about the "War on Christmas" is coming along right on schedule. James Dobson has issued his list of "naughty and nice" retailers, and Donald Wildmon is doing land-office business selling in-your-face buttons and stickers criticizing anyone who fails to say "Merry Christmas" (a nice move during the season of peace).
It's all well and good to leave the carping to Religious Right leaders and blowhards like Bill O'Reilly, but I've been waiting for the other shoe to drop: input from elected officials.
Right on time, state Sen. Chris Buttars of Utah has appeared. Buttars is promoting a resolution encouraging retailers to use the phrase "Merry Christmas" instead of the more generic "Happy Holidays."
"It would encourage the use of `Merry Christmas,'" Buttars told the Salt Lake Tribune. "I'm sick of the Christmas wars - we're a Christian nation and ought to use the word."All I can say is: Amen to that . . . .
There are a couple of points to consider here: One, it's amusing to see right-wing Republicans, who normally adopt a hands-off attitude toward regulating business, trying to force retailers to use certain terms in their ads or in-store greetings. Talk about micro-managing!
As Jim Olsen of the Utah Retail Merchants Association pointed out, Buttars' plan isn't even practical. Many stores these days are owned by national chains, he noted, and decisions about ads and language used is made at home offices, far from Utah.
Buttars would probably argue that the resolution is non-binding. That's true, so what's the point (other than giving Buttars an opportunity for more grandstanding)? If we really want to be serious about this, nothing short of a federal constitutional amendment barring anyone from uttering or printing the phrases "Seasons Greetings" and "Happy Holidays" from Thanksgiving until the Epiphany will do.
Secondly, I must point out to Sen. Buttars that we are not a Christian nation. Our Constitution gives no preference to Christianity. That secular document, in fact, mandates the separation of church and state. (Ironically, America's first "Christian nation" advocates, the Puritans, banned Christmas celebrations. Christmas was not declared a federal holiday until 1870.)
Finally, is this really all Buttars has to do? If my legislator were wasting time on something this frivolous, I'd suggest a long vacation.
Utah Rep. Rep. David Litvack, who is Jewish, pointed this out to the Tribune. Litvack said he has no problem with people wishing him a Merry Christmas but added, "There are many more pressing issues that we've been elected to address. We're a nation of many faiths, and we as leaders should be finding ways to build common ground and respect, not entrenching one side over another."
Buttars says he's sick of the Christmas Wars. I am too. I'm especially sick and tired of the Religious Right's "Christmas Police" trying to tell the rest of us what to say and how to celebrate this month - and now actually trying to bring government pressure to bear! I never had a problem wishing anyone a "Merry Christmas," but this year I'm going out of my way to use something else instead - especially when addressing anyone who has bought into this "War on Christmas" claptrap.
So in that spirit: Happy Holidays, Sen. Buttars!
'Twas the night before Christmas and all through the nation
Friends of Freedom knew it was a special occasion.
Lady Liberty stood taller just off the shore
Her torch shining brighter than a few weeks before
But it wasn't the flame turning her cheeks all rosy
It was thoughts of Snowe, Feingold and Nancy Pelosi
And leaders from every side of the aisle
Who would soon bring the Bill of Rights back into style.
The Amendments had all hurried out of their beds -
Which was no easy task, they were nearly in shreds -
And they rushed to the window on papery feet
As a jolly old man flew right over their street.
"Could it be!?" they inquired as the roof shook and trembled
And they crept toward the mantle, peaceably assembled,
Just as someone emerged from the chimney with flair
In a shiny red suit, with a shock of white hair
And a top hat, and pants all in red, white and blue -
"Wait a minute," the Amendments exclaimed, "Who are you?"
"Don't be frightened my children," he said, "it's no scam.
"You can't have forgotten your old Uncle Sam!"
"Holy crap!" said Free Speech. "Stop right there!" yelled Bear
Arms
And Privacy cried "Who shut off the alarms?!"
The Fifth remained silent, but Uncle Sam said
"We've been having some trouble, but Freedom's not dead."
The Amendments were cautious. "It's just been so long
"We've seen Liberty lost, we've seen so much go wrong.
"The President's trying to mangle and warp us,
"The Fourth is in tatters, so's Habeas Corpus!"
The old man sat down - he had had quite a ride -
But he told them "Don't worry, the Law's on our side,
"'Cause the nation's fed up and more people are crying
"For Justice and an end to illegal spying,
"And secret abductions by the CIA,
"And laws that would take women's choices away,
"And Gitmo tribunals and secret detention,
"And other intrusions too numerous to mention - "
"Not so fast," said a grinchity voice from above
And Don Rumsfeld pushed past the Fourteenth with a shove.
He was covered in soot and he looked kind of scary.
It seemed like his Christmas had not been so merry.
The Amendments said they weren't happy to see him:
"You tried to throw all of us in the museum!
"You've done so much the Constitution forbids!"
"And I would have gone on, but for you meddling kids!"
Uncle Sam told him "Rummy, your plans just won't do,
"So we've got a brand new timetable for you!"
And as Rumsfeld retired and crept into the night
The Amendments cried out "Have a good secret flight!"
From the distance they heard him reply with a snort.
"Bye-bye, Rummy!" they answered, "we'll see you in court!"
Uncle Sam rode the chimney up out of the room
And, like Frosty, he said "I'll be back again soon."
But they heard him exclaim "Oh, and just one more thing!
"This year, when the holiday bells start to ring,
"Try to honor religion. Honest faith can't be wrong.
"It's America, can't we all just get along?
"So, on Christian," he cried, "Muslim, Hindu, and Jew!
"On Quaker! On Shaker! And Atheist too!
"On Buddhist! On Taoist! And to show we're not chickens
"We'll file a few lawsuits defending the Wiccans!
"Your belief is your right, so get out there and savor it.
"Uncle Sam's not a preacher, and he doesn't play favorites!"
So this holiday season, whatever you do,
Warmest wishes for Freedom, from the ACLU.